Skip to content

The Ethics of Belief: Why Clifford Was (Mostly) Right

W.K. Clifford’s Ethics of Belief is treated in survey courses as the warm-up before James’s Will to Believe lands the supposedly decisive counter-punch. James’s argument has merits, but it is narrower than the canonical reading admits, and it leaves Clifford’s main thesis substantially intact for the cases that actually matter to public life.

What Clifford actually claimed

Clifford’s headline thesis — “It is wrong, always, everywhere, and for anyone, to believe anything upon insufficient evidence” — is doing two things. It is asserting (i) that beliefs are subject to moral evaluation, and (ii) that the relevant moral norm is grounded in the social effects of credulity. The famous shipowner example is constructed to make the second point: the shipowner’s belief that his ship is seaworthy is wrong not because of his epistemic state in isolation, but because his credulity is the kind of attitude that, if generalized, makes societies unsafe.

James’s narrower point

James grants that Clifford is right for most beliefs. He carves out an exception for what he calls genuine options: live, forced, momentous choices that cannot be settled by evidence. The classic case is religious belief. James’s argument is good for that range. It is misread when extended to political beliefs about empirical matters — vaccine safety, election integrity, climate — which are neither forced nor evidentially undecidable.

The contemporary problem is not that we have insufficiently appreciated James. It is that we have read him as licensing what Clifford was right to forbid.

The neglected piece

What I think is missing from current debates is Clifford’s social epistemology. He was not interested in the lone believer. He was interested in the conditions under which a society’s belief-formation practices can be trusted at all. By that measure, the question “do I have the right to believe this?” is always also the question “what kind of community of inquirers am I helping to make?” The answer to the second question can settle the first.

More from this kitchen

2 thoughts

  1. A welcome corrective. The James-as-pluralist reading has done more damage than its defenders admit.

  2. I would add Goldberg on the social ethics of testimony as a natural successor to Clifford here.

Comments are closed on this post.