A Note on Decisive Reasons in Normative Ethics
The term “decisive reason” is used in two distinct senses in the contemporary literature. The conflation between them is a source of recurring confusion.
The term “decisive reason” is used in two distinct senses in the contemporary literature. The conflation between them is a source of recurring confusion.
Standard accounts of practical rationality treat each decision as the locus of evaluation. I want to suggest the locus is sometimes the pattern of decisions, not the individual.
A familiar slide in practical reasoning: from "there is most reason to φ" to "φ is required." The two claims are distinct, and the distinction matters.