Skip to content

Moral Luck, Twenty Years In: Why I Stopped Trying to Eliminate It

The Williams-Nagel papers on moral luck were supposed to expose a tension in our ordinary moral thinking and prompt us to resolve it — either by retreating to a Kantian fortress where only the will is judged, or by expanding our conception of agency to include the contingent. The literature ever since has largely tried to do one or the other. I no longer think either move works, and I no longer think either was supposed to.

The four kinds, recapped

  • Resultant luck — how things turn out (the swerving truck driver who hits a child vs. one who doesn’t).
  • Circumstantial luck — the situations one happens to face.
  • Constitutive luck — the character one happens to have.
  • Causal luck — the prior causes of one’s choices.

The standard Kantian response — only constitutive matters under one’s control are properly subject to moral assessment — is correct as a piece of pure reasoning and disastrous as an account of what we actually do. We blame the swerving driver more, even when his swerving was identical to his lucky counterpart. We praise the resistor of an injustice we never had to face. We do this systematically, not as a slip.

Either our practice is incoherent, or our theory of agency is too thin. After twenty years of grading papers on the topic, I think it is the latter.

Toward a thicker account

What we are doing when we hold someone accountable for an outcome is not (only) tracking what they controlled. We are also tracking what their action came to mean — what it now stands for in the moral landscape we share. That is partly luck. It is also partly real. The truck driver who killed a child has done something that now requires a different reckoning than the one who did not. Our practice tracks that reckoning. It is not confused.

More from this kitchen

2 thoughts

  1. Have you read Enoch on the moral significance of the inevitable? He pushes a related line.

  2. I want to resist the conclusion but I think you are right about what we actually do.

Comments are closed on this post.