Skip to content

The Ethics of Self-Deception: When Lying to Yourself Becomes a Wrong to Others

Self-deception sits in an uncomfortable place between weakness of will and outright dishonesty. It looks inward and feels self-contained — as if the only person being misled is the one doing the misleading. That framing is, I think, a mistake. It lets us treat self-deception as a sort of private hygiene problem, when it is more often a strategy for offloading moral costs onto other people.

Three quick cases

  • The manager who “genuinely doesn’t realize” that her reorganization will gut the team.
  • The colleague who “didn’t mean it that way” after a remark that he had every reason to know would land badly.
  • The donor who “believes” the foundation does good work and so doesn’t look at the audited reports.

In each case the self-deception is doing real work. It permits the agent to enjoy the benefits of a belief whose costs other people are absorbing.

Bratman’s grip

Michael Bratman has argued that what distinguishes self-deception from mere ignorance is that the agent maintains a particular kind of motivated interpretive control over their own evidence. The self-deceived person is not just wrong — they are steering. That steering is what makes the act answerable to others.

The wrong of self-deception, when there is one, is not that you fooled yourself. It is that you arranged your inner life so that you would not have to be moved by what you owed someone else to know.

What this changes

If this is right, then we cannot fully evaluate the morality of self-deception by looking at the deceived agent in isolation. We have to ask: who else’s standing to make a claim on you did this belief conveniently neutralize? That is the question I want to put to my own self-deceptions. It is rarely a comfortable one.

More from this kitchen

Moral Psychology

Moral Luck Revisited

Williams and Nagel introduced the problem of moral luck nearly fifty years ago. In its standard formulation, the problem is this: our…

NatashaFebruary 11, 2025

One thought

  1. Sharp framing. The “steering” point is important. Reminds me of Velleman on agency without authorship.

Comments are closed on this post.