Skip to content

Public Philosophy and the Audience Problem

Public philosophy is having a moment. The number of philosophers writing for non-philosophical audiences — in newspapers, in policy briefs, in podcasts, on blogs — has grown substantially in the past decade, and the institutional pressure to engage in such writing has grown alongside it. The moment is producing a literature that, I want to suggest, has not adequately addressed the question of who it is for.

The standard framing treats public philosophy as the translation of philosophical work into a register accessible to general audiences. The philosopher does her academic work, and then, in a separate operation, she translates that work for a broader public. The translation is held to be a virtue, but a derivative one — the real work is the academic work, and the public work is a kind of generous explanatory afterthought.

I think this framing is wrong, and the framing has consequences.

Who is the public?

The first problem with the standard framing is that it treats “the public” as a unitary audience. It is not. The audience for a piece of public philosophy in a major newspaper is different from the audience for a podcast episode is different from the audience for a policy brief. These audiences differ in their background knowledge, their motivations for engagement, the time they are willing to spend, and the conclusions they are looking for.

Treating these audiences as a single “public” obscures the choices the philosopher is making. The newspaper essay can assume a curious general reader; the podcast can assume a partial attention; the policy brief can assume a domain expert with limited time. The same philosophical content, addressed to these three audiences, becomes three different pieces of work.

Translation or production?

The second problem is the framing of public philosophy as translation. The implication is that there is a finished philosophical product upstream, and the public-facing piece is downstream. But for many of the most interesting questions in public philosophy — questions about technology, about pandemic response, about climate policy — there is no finished academic product to translate. The public-facing work is doing original philosophical work, and the academic literature, where it exists, is lagging.

This is not a marginal observation. Some of the most important philosophical reflection of the past decade has happened in public venues, not in journals. The journals are reckoning with this reckoning with delays of years.

If we keep the translation framing, we will continue to assess public philosophy by criteria appropriate to translation: fidelity to the original, accessibility, absence of distortion. We will fail to assess it by criteria appropriate to original work: novelty, insight, methodological care, openness to refutation.

What this means for practice

If the framing I have suggested is right, two things follow.

First, philosophers writing for public audiences should think more carefully about who they are writing for. The unitary “public” is a placeholder for an audience the philosopher has not yet identified. Identifying it — making explicit what knowledge, motivations, and constraints the reader brings — is the first step toward writing well.

Second, the discipline should be more willing to recognize public-facing work as original philosophical contribution. This does not mean every newspaper essay deserves credit alongside a journal article. But it does mean the binary — serious work for the academy, lighter work for the public — is too crude.

A modest proposal

I will close with a small suggestion. When a philosopher writes a public-facing piece, she should be encouraged — perhaps required, in some institutional contexts — to name the audience explicitly. Not in the published piece, where naming the audience would be condescending, but in some accompanying note: “This piece was written for X audience, with Y prior knowledge, under Z constraints.”

This would, I think, improve the quality of public philosophy in two ways. It would force the philosopher to be honest about the choices she was making, and it would give readers a way to evaluate whether the piece succeeds at what it is trying to do. Right now, the criteria are implicit and the work is correspondingly hard to assess.

I am open to objections, particularly from those who think the unitary “public” framing is doing useful work I have not appreciated.

More from this kitchen

Methodology

Reflective Equilibrium: A Note on Method

Reflective equilibrium — the method, due originally to Rawls, of moving back and forth between considered judgments, candidate principles, and background theories…

NatashaDecember 5, 2024

Add your two pesos

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *